Rubrik's July quarter was the cleanest print in our coverage: Subscription ARR $1.66B, up 33%, revenue $427.3M, up 38%, non-GAAP EPS of $0.20 against a $0.04 consensus, free cash flow of $65.7M, and every full-year metric raised. The FY27 guide now calls for $1.88B of Subscription ARR (about +29%), $1.69B of revenue and $323–333M of free cash flow, and 28 of 29 analysts rate it Buy with an average target of $113. Nothing in the thesis has weakened since our Sep 1 note. The price has. The stock is up 130% from its April low and rose 12% today to $97.38 on volume with no company news we could find; the nearest items are a Wedbush initiation on Sep 11 and a Goldman conference appearance the same day. At about $19.6B of enterprise value the shares trade 11.6x the FY27 revenue guide and about 60x guided free cash flow, GAAP losses ran $103.6M in the first half with $174M of stock-based compensation, book equity is negative $499M against $1.13B of converts, and four insiders sold about $12M under pre-set plans since mid-July with no buying. Our fair value of about $107 gives 10% upside, which is inside the noise for a stock with 54% implied volatility. We move to HOLD from BUY on price, not on fundamentals, and would re-enter at the 50-day average near $88, where the same thesis buys 20% more.
| Company | P/E (fwd) | EV/Rev | Rev Growth | Gross Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rubrik | ≈195x non-GAAP | 11.6x FY27 guide (11.3x TTM) | +38% (Q2 FY27) | 78.4% GAAP / 81.0% non-GAAP |
| CrowdStrike | 146.6x | 38.5x TTM | TTM revenue $5.4B | 75.2% |
| Zscaler | 33.5x | 7.52x TTM | 16% 3-yr forecast | 76.9% |
| Commvault | 25.5x | 4.68x TTM | 11% 3-yr forecast | 81.1% |
| Method | Implied Value / Share | Weight | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| EV / Sales on FY28 | $111 | 40% | FY28 (Jan 2028) revenue of about $2.09B, our +24% on the $1.69B FY27 guide, at 11x, which is where a 29–33% ARR grower with a 20% FCF margin sits between Zscaler (7.5x, mid-teens growth) and CrowdStrike (38.5x, platform premium). EV $23.0B plus about $0.9B of net cash after FY27 FCF, over about 215M diluted shares. |
| EV / Free cash flow on FY28 | $98 | 30% | FY28 FCF of about $450M (21% margin, up from the 19–20% FY27 guide) at 45x = $20.3B, plus net cash, over 215M shares. This is the method that says the price already discounts the FCF ramp. |
| EV / Subscription ARR | $109 | 30% | FY27 ARR guide midpoint $1.88B at 12x = $22.6B, plus net cash, over 215M shares. 12x ARR is a premium to the sector median that the 35% net-new-ARR growth and 119%-plus retention justify for now. |
| Blended estimate | $107 | 100% | +10% vs. the $97.38 intraday price — inside the noise for a stock with 54% implied volatility |
The three methods bracket $98 to $111 and blend to about $107, ten percent above today's price. On Sep 1 the same framework gave $111 against a $93 price and supported a BUY; since then the fundamentals have not changed and the price has run 5% on the close and 12% intraday today without news. A 10% weighted upside on a stock that moves 12% in a session is not a BUY signal, it is a hold. The thesis stays intact: the re-entry point is the 50-day average near $88, where fair value is 22% away.
| Scenario | Price Target | Assumptions | Probability |
|---|---|---|---|
| ARR growth holds above 30%, FCF margin expands | $135 | Net new ARR keeps compounding at 30%-plus on identity resilience and agent security, FY28 ARR reaches about $2.4B with FCF margin toward 25%, and the market pays 13x FY28 revenue. This is the Street high (Citi $130 to $135) and requires the Q3 and Q4 prints to beat and raise again. | 30% |
| Guide met, growth decelerates to the mid-20s | $111 | FY27 lands inside the raised guide, FY28 revenue grows about 24% with FCF of roughly $450M, and the multiple holds at 11x forward sales. Dilution runs at the guided pace (about 230M shares) rather than the 18% bears cite. | 45% |
| Deceleration plus multiple compression | $68 | Net new ARR growth slips toward 20% as Cohesity-Veritas, Commvault and Veeam press pricing, FCF is squeezed by shorter billing terms, and the stock re-rates to Zscaler's 7x sales on FY28 revenue of about $2.0B. That is roughly the 200-day average and where the stock traded in July. | 25% |